CHINA → USA · CUSTOMS VALUATION · 19 U.S.C. §1401A · 19 CFR PART 152
U.S. Customs Valuation: Transaction Value, Six Methods & China Import Examples
U.S. customs value is not simply the number printed at the bottom of a supplier invoice, and it is not automatically the total of goods, international freight and insurance. For most merchandise sold for export to the United States the primary method is transaction value — the price actually paid or payable, adjusted by the additions and exclusions U.S. law requires.
Transaction valueFive statutory additionsSix appraisal methodsAssists and royaltiesFirst Sale evidence
Official-source methodology · Federal Register / CBP / eCFR · Last verified November 19, 2026
QUICK ANSWER
Which valuation method applies, and what belongs in the number
Under 19 U.S.C. §1401a and 19 CFR Part 152, imported merchandise is appraised under a hierarchy of valuation methods. The first method is usually transaction value.
For a China-origin shipment, the useful question is not “what number is on the invoice?”. It is “which method applies, what payments belong in that value, what amounts can be excluded, and what evidence supports the result?”
Transaction value starts with the price actually paid or payable and, when applicable and not already included, adds packing costs incurred by the buyer, selling commissions incurred by the buyer, the apportioned value of assists, qualifying royalties or license fees, and qualifying proceeds of a subsequent resale, disposal or use that accrue to the seller.
price actually paid or payable + applicable statutory additions, exclusive of qualifying international transportation, insurance and related international-shipment services
The statute defines price actually paid or payable as the total payment made or to be made by the buyer to, or for the benefit of, the seller — exclusive of qualifying transportation, insurance and related international-shipment costs. That is why a commercial invoice total is not automatically customs value, and why CIF-style landed-cost arithmetic is not automatically U.S. transaction value.
THE HIERARCHY
The six U.S. customs valuation methods
19 CFR §152.101 establishes the order. The methods are applied in sequence, not chosen as six interchangeable numbers.
The importer may request computed value before deductive value. Under 19 CFR §152.101(c) that request must be made when the entry summary is filed.
Order
Valuation method
When it is considered
1
Transaction value
Primary method when the statutory requirements are satisfied
2
Transaction value of identical merchandise
If transaction value cannot be determined or cannot be used
3
Transaction value of similar merchandise
If an acceptable identical-merchandise value is unavailable
4
Deductive value
If the prior methods cannot determine value
5
Computed value
If deductive value cannot determine value
6
Method under 19 CFR §152.107
If computed value cannot determine value; the earlier methods are reasonably adjusted within the permitted framework
This is a legal hierarchy, not six interchangeable results from which an importer selects the lowest. A lower number obtained out of sequence is not a valuation method.
METHOD 1
Transaction value — the primary method
USITC describes transaction value — the price actually paid or payable when the goods are sold — as the primary basis for customs value.
Under 19 CFR §152.103, transaction value generally requires:
Conditions to establish
Merchandise sold for exportation to the United States
An identifiable price actually paid or payable
Any required statutory additions identified
Sufficient information to quantify those additions
No disqualifying restriction or condition
Acceptable related-party treatment where buyer and seller are related
The strongest valuation file connects the number declared on entry to the actual commercial transaction.
Additions — only when applicable and not already included
An addition is made only when it is not already inside the price actually paid or payable, and only when sufficient information exists to determine the amount.
Statutory addition
What it covers
Packing costs incurred by the buyer
Packing the buyer pays for, where the seller has not already included it in the price
Selling commissions incurred by the buyer
A commission paid to the seller’s agent — a buying commission is a different question
Assists, apportioned as appropriate
Buyer-supplied materials, tooling, consumed merchandise, or qualifying foreign engineering and design
Qualifying royalties or license fees
Payments related to the imported merchandise and required as a condition of the sale
Proceeds of a subsequent resale, disposal or use
Where the proceeds accrue to the seller
If sufficient information does not exist for a required addition, transaction value may become unavailable. That is a change of method, not a reason to enter an estimated number.
DECISION MATRIX
What belongs in customs value — and what may not
Use this as a decision matrix, not as a substitute for shipment-specific review. A cost label by itself does not decide its customs treatment.
The word “review” is intentional. It means the documents decide the treatment, not the invoice line name.
Cost or payment
General U.S. valuation treatment
Planning status
Purchase price paid to the seller
Starting point for transaction value
Include
Buyer-paid packing
Statutory addition if not already included
Add
Selling commission
Statutory addition if not already included
Add
Bona fide buying commission
Not one of the five statutory additions, but the agency facts must support the treatment
Review
Buyer-supplied mold, die or tooling
Can be an assist
Review / add if applicable
Buyer-supplied materials or components
Can be an assist
Review / add if applicable
Foreign engineering or design necessary for production
Can be an assist
Review / add if applicable
U.S.-performed qualifying design work
May fall outside the assist definition under the regulation
Review
Royalty or license fee
Can be dutiable if related to the imported merchandise and required as a condition of sale
Review / add if applicable
Resale proceeds returned to the seller
Statutory addition
Add if applicable
International freight
Excluded from the statutory definition of price actually paid or payable when it qualifies as international-shipment transportation; foreign inland freight requires separate review
Review / usually separate
International insurance
Excluded from that definition when it qualifies under the international-shipment rule
Review / usually separate
Post-import U.S. transportation
Excluded when the statutory requirements are satisfied and the amount is separately identified
Exclude from transaction value
U.S. customs duties and specified federal taxes
Excluded when separately identified under the statute
Exclude from transaction value
Post-import construction, assembly, maintenance or qualifying technical assistance
Can be excluded when separately identified and the statutory requirements are satisfied
Review
NOT AUTOMATICALLY CIF
Customs value and landed cost are two different calculations
For U.S. imports, “goods value + freight + insurance = customs value” is not a universal legal rule.
The U.S. transaction-value statute defines price actually paid or payable to exclude qualifying costs, charges and expenses for transportation, insurance and related services incident to the international shipment from the country of exportation to the U.S. place of importation. That is a statutory exclusion, not a CIF build-up.
Customs valuation
Used to establish the appraised value for customs purposes under the applicable method.
It is decided by the transaction, the statutory additions and exclusions, and the evidence that supports each figure.
Landed cost
A business-planning total that can include product cost, China pickup, origin handling, international freight, insurance, customs duties, government fees, broker and bond, terminal and port costs, U.S. inland delivery, and warehouse or appointment charges.
These numbers interact, but they are not interchangeable.
Landed cost calculator → — a planning tool. It takes the customs value for duty as a separate input rather than building one from a CIF formula.
FREIGHT NUANCE
Foreign inland freight: do not oversimplify
This is where a generic “freight is excluded” statement becomes wrong. 19 CFR §152.103(a)(5) turns on what the seller’s price includes.
Ex-factory sale
If the price paid to the seller does not include foreign inland freight and other shipment charges, those charges are not automatically added to the price.
Sale where the price includes it
If the price paid to the seller does include foreign inland freight, the charge is generally part of transaction value to the extent it is included.
Qualifying foreign inland freight and related services may be treated as incident to international shipment when the regulatory conditions are met, including evidence of sale for export and placement for through shipment to the United States.
For China purchases, keep these separate in the transaction file where possible:
Keep separable
Factory price
Pickup and inland transport
Export handling
International freight
Insurance
Do not create artificial deductions. Any claimed treatment must be supported by the actual sale and shipment documents — not by the label on a cost line.
ASSISTS
Assists: the China sourcing issue importers often miss
An assist can exist when the buyer supplies goods or services, directly or indirectly, free of charge or at reduced cost, for use in producing the imported merchandise.
19 CFR §152.102 includes categories such as:
materials, components, parts and similar items incorporated in the merchandise;
tools, dies, molds and similar items used in production;
merchandise consumed in production;
specified engineering, development, artwork, design work, plans and sketches undertaken outside the United States and necessary for production.
A U.S. buyer may purchase a mold and send it to a Shenzhen factory, give the supplier components without charge, pay a third-country engineering company for production drawings used by the factory, or supply packaging at reduced cost.
The supplier invoice can still show only the unit price. That does not mean the assist disappears from the valuation analysis.
Tooling example
A U.S. importer pays a China factory $50,000 for 10,000 finished units, and separately owns a mold supplied free of charge to the factory with a supportable assist value of $10,000.
Do not automatically declare customs value as $50,000. First determine:
01
Is the mold an assist?
Confirm the item falls within the assist definition rather than a service the buyer purchased for itself.
02
What is the correct assist value?
Acquisition cost and the supporting invoice or valuation evidence, not a guess.
03
What did transport add?
Where applicable, transportation to the place of production can form part of the assist value.
04
What is the reasonable apportionment?
19 CFR §152.103 allows reasonable apportionment appropriate to the circumstances, supported by documentation.
05
Is any part already in the price?
Tooling amortised into the unit price is not added a second time.
ROYALTIES
Royalties and license fees are not automatically dutiable
19 CFR §152.103 focuses on whether the payment relates to the imported merchandise, and whether the buyer is required to pay it as a condition of the sale for export.
Payments to third parties for U.S. distribution or resale rights can receive different treatment where they are not a condition of the sale for export.
Questions to ask
Who receives the royalty?
What agreement creates the payment?
Is payment required for the imported goods to be sold to the buyer?
Is the fee calculated only on the imported merchandise?
Is it tied to manufacturing rights, trademark use, distribution rights or another right?
Is the seller or a related party involved?
Do not decide royalty treatment from the invoice line name alone.
RELATED PARTIES
A related-party sale does not automatically fail transaction value
“Buyer and seller are related, so transaction value cannot be used” is a common oversimplification — and it is not the rule.
19 CFR §152.103 provides that a related-party transaction value can be acceptable if:
examination of the circumstances of sale shows the relationship did not influence the price; or
the transaction value closely approximates an appropriate test value.
The regulation also states that CBP should not disregard a transaction value solely because the buyer and seller are related.
Related-party decision path
01
Are buyer and seller related?
If no, continue normal transaction-value review.
02
Did the relationship influence the price?
Evidence can include how the parties organise the relationship, how the price was established, whether pricing follows normal industry practice, and whether it is consistent with sales to unrelated buyers.
03
Are suitable test values available?
The regulation provides test-value comparisons, including qualifying values for identical or similar merchandise exported at or about the same time.
04
Record a result state
Transaction value appears supportable, additional related-party evidence required, or an alternative valuation method may be required.
Do not force every related-party shipment into a yes/no answer from a single transfer-pricing document. A transfer-pricing study is not, by itself, the customs circumstances-of-sale analysis.
FIRST SALE
First Sale: potentially important, never automatic
A multi-tier China transaction can look like China factory → Hong Kong or trading-company middleman → U.S. importer. In qualifying circumstances an earlier sale may support transaction value.
But First Sale is not an automatic tariff-reduction election. Recent CBP rulings continue to examine the actual transaction documents closely. A First Sale file may need to establish:
What the file must establish
A bona fide sale
The earlier sale was for exportation to the United States
The merchandise was clearly destined for the United States at the relevant time
The transaction is acceptable under the applicable valuation rules
Related-party issues are resolved where relevant
Statutory additions are captured
Documents reconcile across the chain
Typical evidence
Purchase orders, commercial invoices, proof of payment, contracts, factory-to-middleman documents, middleman-to-importer documents, manufacturing records where relevant, shipping records, and pricing or relationship support.
If the evidence is incomplete, the correct output is “First Sale eligibility requires specialist review” — never a lower value calculated automatically.
NO SALE
What if there is no sale?
Free commercial samples, consignment inventory, intercompany transfers that are not a sale, certain returns and no-charge demonstration goods all raise the same question.
Do not assume that no sale means a customs value of zero. If transaction value cannot be used, the valuation hierarchy continues and the importer and its customs professional may need to consider, in order:
transaction value of identical merchandise;
transaction value of similar merchandise;
deductive value;
computed value;
the method under §152.107.
METHODS 2–6
What the alternative methods actually require
Each step down the hierarchy has its own evidence requirement. None of them is a shortcut to a lower number.
Method 2 — transaction value of identical merchandise
This method uses an acceptable transaction value of imported merchandise identical to the merchandise being appraised, exported to the United States at or about the same time, subject to the regulatory adjustments. Considerations include commercial level, quantity, applicable adjustments and sufficient information.
It is not “find the same product online and use that price”.
Method 3 — transaction value of similar merchandise
If an acceptable identical-merchandise value cannot be found, similar merchandise can be considered under §152.104. “Similar” is a customs concept, not a marketing comparison: the regulation looks to characteristics and component materials and whether the merchandise is commercially interchangeable, subject to the statutory and regulatory framework.
Method 4 — deductive value
Deductive value generally works backward from qualifying U.S. sales of the imported merchandise, or qualifying identical or similar merchandise, with the regulatory deductions. It can require reliable U.S. resale data, and the actual deductions and timing requirements are controlled by 19 U.S.C. §1401a(d) and 19 CFR §152.105.
It should not be summarised as “U.S. retail price minus profit”.
Method 5 — computed value
19 U.S.C. §1401a(e) builds value from production economics: the cost or value of materials, fabrication and other processing, profit and general expenses, assists not already included, and packing. In practice this method can be difficult where the foreign producer cannot or will not provide the required information; 19 CFR §152.106 addresses that limitation.
Method 6 — value under §152.107
If the preceding methods cannot determine value, §152.107 permits appraisement using a value derived from the earlier statutory methods, reasonably adjusted as necessary within the legal framework.
It is not “CBP may choose any reasonable value”. The method still operates inside the statutory system and does not authorise arbitrary or fictitious values.
CHINA EXAMPLES
Three China-to-USA valuation examples
Each example shows the same discipline: start from the method, then test the additions, then test the evidence.
A — direct factory sale
A U.S. importer buys finished storage products directly from a Ningbo factory: purchase price $24,000, unrelated buyer and seller, no separate royalty, no buyer-provided mold, international freight billed separately.
Likely starting point: transaction value review.
The importer should retain the purchase order, commercial invoice, proof of payment, freight invoice, product records and records showing whether any additions exist.
Do not add international freight merely because it appears in a landed-cost worksheet.
B — buyer provides a mold
A U.S. private-label company pays a Dongguan factory $60,000 for manufactured goods and separately supplies a production mold free of charge.
The review asks whether the mold is an assist, what its supportable value is, whether transport to the production site affected that value, how the value should be apportioned, and whether any portion is already inside the supplier price.
This is why the commercial invoice alone can be insufficient.
C — China factory → middleman → U.S. importer
A factory sells goods to a Hong Kong trading company, which resells them to the U.S. importer. The importer wants to use the factory-to-middleman price.
Do not assume the lower first price controls. Review the bona fide sale, destination to the United States, parties and relationships, purchase orders, invoices, payment evidence, shipping documentation, statutory additions and the current CBP ruling approach.
Result: First Sale review required, until the transaction evidence supports the position.
DECISION SUPPORT
U.S. Customs Value Decision Worksheet
This block helps you move from “I have an invoice number” to “I know whether transaction value can be modelled, what additions need evidence, and when specialist review is required”.
It is not a binding customs-value calculator. It stores nothing, sends nothing, and adds nothing to the page address. When the method itself is unresolved — no sale, an addition with an unknown amount, an unresolved royalty, an unvalidated related-party price, a First Sale structure, or an unsupported transport deduction — it withholds a value and lists the reasons instead.
Answer the sale question to begin. Nothing you enter is stored, sent or added to the page address.
Planning support only. This worksheet does not determine the customs value CBP will accept and does not replace the importer’s reasonable-care obligations or advice from an authorized customs professional.
EVIDENCE
Documents to prepare before the broker reviews value
The valuation file should let someone else re-derive the declared number without asking you a question.
Then combine the customs result with freight and destination expenses for business planning: landed cost calculator →. That tool takes the customs value for duty as a separate input rather than manufacturing one from a CIF formula.
When to request a CBP ruling or a specialist valuation review
Some value questions are not worth answering internally. Consider formal or specialist review when:
Escalate when
Classification or value has a large duty impact
The same SKU will be imported repeatedly
First Sale is proposed
Buyer and seller are related
Royalty treatment is unclear
A major assist exists
The transaction has post-import price adjustments
No clear sale for export exists
A new business structure changes the importer or pricing chain
The broker and importer reach materially different valuation conclusions
A dedicated DDP Atlas guide on CBP binding rulings and on importer recordkeeping is planned but not yet published. Until those pages exist, use CBP’s own ruling resources and CROSS, linked in the official sources below.
MISTAKES
Common valuation mistakes
Most of these come from treating a commercial label as a legal rule.
Mistake
Better approach
Declaring the invoice total without reviewing additions
Start with the transaction and test each statutory addition
Adding freight and insurance automatically to create “customs value”
Apply the U.S. valuation statute and keep landed-cost arithmetic separate
Removing every charge labelled “freight”
Review international and foreign-inland treatment against the actual sale and shipping facts
Ignoring buyer-owned molds
Screen for assists before the entry is filed
Treating all royalties the same
Review the relationship to the goods and the condition of sale
Rejecting transaction value because the parties are related
Apply the circumstances-of-sale or test-value analysis
Using the first factory price because it is lower
Establish First Sale eligibility with evidence
Declaring free samples at zero
Apply the valuation hierarchy when transaction value is unavailable
Treating Incoterms as valuation law
Use Incoterms as commercial context, not as the valuation method
Treating a DDP price as the declared customs value
Separate goods, transport, duty, services and the legal valuation analysis
PRE-ENTRY
Pre-entry customs-value checklist
Run this before the entry is filed, not after CBP asks a question.
Method
Sale-for-export status established
Primary valuation method identified
Alternative method considered if transaction value is unavailable
Price
Price actually paid or payable documented
Payment trail available
Discounts and credits documented
Post-import price adjustments reviewed
Additions
Packing reviewed
Selling commissions reviewed
Assists reviewed
Royalties and license fees reviewed
Resale proceeds reviewed
Freight
International freight separately identified
Insurance separately identified
Foreign inland freight treatment reviewed
Shipping documentation supports the claimed treatment
Relationships
Buyer and seller relationship checked
Related-party evidence prepared if applicable
Multi-tier or First Sale structure reviewed if applicable
Recordkeeping
Commercial invoice retained
Purchase orders and contracts retained
Payment records retained
Assist evidence retained
Royalty agreements retained
Freight evidence retained
Valuation working paper retained
KEEP GOING
Related guides and tools
COMMON QUESTIONS
U.S. customs valuation FAQ
What is U.S. customs value?
It is the appraised value determined under the U.S. customs valuation statute and regulations. Transaction value is the primary method when its requirements are satisfied.
Is customs value the same as invoice value?
Not necessarily. The invoice can be the starting point, but statutory additions, exclusions, transaction structure and the selected valuation method can change the appraised value.
Is freight included in U.S. customs value?
Do not apply a universal yes/no rule to every charge. The statute excludes qualifying international transportation, insurance and related services from the definition of price actually paid or payable, while foreign inland freight has additional regulatory rules.
Is insurance included?
Qualifying international-shipment insurance is excluded from the statutory definition of price actually paid or payable, but the actual documentation and transaction structure still matter.
Is a mold supplied to my China factory dutiable?
A buyer-supplied mold can be an assist. Its value and reasonable apportionment must be reviewed under the regulations.
Are related-party prices allowed?
Yes, potentially. Related-party status alone does not invalidate transaction value. The importer may need to establish that the relationship did not influence the price or satisfy an applicable test-value analysis.
Can I use the factory price if a trading company is involved?
Only if the earlier sale qualifies under the applicable First Sale rules and the evidence supports that position. Do not use the lower price automatically.
What value should I use for free samples?
Do not assume zero. If transaction value is unavailable, the statutory hierarchy of alternative valuation methods must be considered.
Is DDP price the customs value?
Not automatically. A DDP commercial amount can combine goods, freight, insurance, duties, destination delivery and services. Those components must be separated and the valuation rules applied to the actual transaction.
Can the DDP Atlas calculator determine my legal customs value?
No. It helps structure planning inputs. The importer and its authorized customs professionals remain responsible for the customs value declared on entry.
OFFICIAL SOURCES
Statute, regulation, USITC and CBP sources behind this page
The statute and the eCFR control. USITC and CBP material is used for the operational explanation, and CROSS is the entry point for rulings.
Last verified: November 19, 2026. Valuation rulings, methods and the tariff schedule change; re-check the actual transaction and the evidence before declaring a value.
CHINA-ORIGIN FREIGHT
Establish the customs-value inputs before the cargo leaves China
DDP Atlas can coordinate factory pickup, shipment records, supplier documents, consolidation and freight planning while the importer and its authorized customs professionals establish the valuation method and entry value.
This page provides general U.S. import-planning information based on official sources reviewed on November 19, 2026. It is not a customs ruling, legal opinion, transfer-pricing opinion, valuation determination or instruction to declare a specific value. The actual appraisal method and declared value depend on the transaction and the supporting evidence.